45 Wins, 26 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/20/87 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 55 | Kennedy 64 | League | 0.004 |
| 01/31/87 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 57 | Auburn 49 | League | 11.840 |
| 01/31/87 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 56 | Renton 46 | League | 10.386 |
| 02/06/87 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 53 | Hazen 55 | League | 1.993 |
| 02/14/87 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) L | Kennedy W | Playoff | 0.004 |
| 12/05/87 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 48 | Federal Way 60 | Non-league | 1.504 |
| Won | Evergreen (Highline) 57 | Kennedy 44 | League | 4.382 | |
| 01/20/89 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 53 | Renton 38 | League | 8.798 |
| 11/28/89 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 38 | Nathan Hale 43 | Non-league | 4.623 |
| 12/12/89 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 38 | Tyee 43 | League | 1.716 |
| 12/19/89 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) W | Renton L | League | 13.436 |
| 01/05/90 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) W | Hazen L | League | 13.568 |
| 01/12/90 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 44 | Mount Rainier 43 | League | 13.381 |
| 02/06/90 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 42 | Highline 38 | League | 5.709 |
| 01/11/91 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 55 | Mount Rainier 57 | League | 13.716 |
| 01/12/91 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 38 | Mount Si 46 | League | 4.167 |
| 01/18/91 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 60 | Lindbergh 36 | League | 2.044 |
| 02/01/91 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 59 | Hazen 52 | League | 18.182 |
| 02/05/91 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 51 | Highline 52 | League | 13.073 |
| 12/10/91 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 44 | Tyee 45 | League | 0.231 |
| 01/31/92 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 51 | Mount Rainier 54 | League | 12.823 |
| 01/12/93 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 31 | Renton 34 | League | 12.791 |
| 02/05/93 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 44 | Mount Rainier 31 | League | 1.135 |
| 02/16/93 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 52 | Mount Si 51 | League | 0.927 |
| 12/14/93 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 41 | Lindbergh 36 | League | 5.510 |
| 01/13/95 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) L | Hazen W | League | 0.225 |
| 02/10/95 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 34 | Renton 40 | League | 0.356 |
| 02/11/95 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 31 | Hazen 55 | League | 0.225 |
| 02/14/95 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 48 | Mount Rainier 47 | League | 12.253 |
| 12/19/95 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) W | Tyee L | League | 11.316 |
| 01/16/96 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) W | Lindbergh L | League | 14.222 |
| 01/19/96 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 58 | Mount Rainier 53 | League | 8.038 |
| 01/25/96 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) W | Hazen L | League | 6.165 |
| 02/09/96 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 43 | Renton 41 | League | 5.396 |
| 12/19/96 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) W | Hazen L | League | 2.679 |
| 01/07/97 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 36 | Tyee 42 | League | 10.824 |
| 02/13/97 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 35 | Renton 37 | League | 3.291 |
| 12/17/98 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 36 | Tyee 46 | League | 6.575 |
| 01/19/99 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 57 | Renton 52 | League | 7.485 |
| 02/12/99 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 46 | Renton 39 | League | 7.485 |
| 01/12/00 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 47 | Mount Rainier 45 | League | 1.190 |
| 02/15/00 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 43 | Seattle Prep 40 | Playoff | 21.344 |
| 12/12/00 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 33 | Hazen 37 | League | 2.757 |
| 12/14/00 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 33 | Highline 43 | League | 1.600 |
| 01/12/01 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 51 | Tyee 33 | League | 1.677 |
| 12/19/01 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 47 | Hazen 46 | League | 2.630 |
| 02/03/03 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 49 | Hazen 37 | League | 5.651 |
| 12/05/03 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 45 | Washington 54 | Non-league | 5.587 |
| 12/09/03 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 49 | Franklin Pierce 48 | Non-league | 10.291 |
| 12/16/03 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 53 | Hazen 51 | League | 0.373 |
| 01/13/04 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 42 | Highline 40 | League | 2.174 |
| 02/06/04 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 63 | Highline 56 | League | 2.174 |
| 11/30/04 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 64 | Peninsula 52 | Non-league | 2.849 |
| 12/03/04 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 49 | Fife 57 | Non-league | 10.772 |
| 12/10/04 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 48 | Mount Rainier 46 | League | 3.279 |
| 01/07/05 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 51 | Lindbergh 41 | League | 3.840 |
| 01/24/05 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 60 | Highline 63 | League | 4.825 |
| 12/06/05 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 51 | Clover Park 53 | Non-league | 2.769 |
| 12/09/05 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 61 | Mount Rainier 56 | League | 1.106 |
| 02/11/06 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 57 | Peninsula 52 | Playoff | 5.797 |
| 01/26/07 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 50 | Mount Rainier 39 | League | 6.765 |
| 02/06/07 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 47 | Hazen 44 | League | 5.299 |
| 02/03/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 30 | Highline 27 | League | 12.406 |
| 12/05/11 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 49 | Rainier Beach 32 | Non-league | 3.013 |
| 01/23/13 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 32 | Highline 29 | League | 2.677 |
| 01/15/14 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 45 | Hazen 51 | League | 5.766 |
| 01/27/14 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 49 | Lakewood 37 | Non-league | 3.827 |
| 02/13/14 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 53 | Tyee 49 | Playoff | 5.893 |
| 12/06/14 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 39 | Mount Rainier 43 | Non-league | 2.440 |
| 12/10/14 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 44 | Hazen 39 | League | 1.783 |
| 01/16/15 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 48 | Hazen 39 | League | 1.783 |
37 Wins, 17 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/11/02 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 63 | Franklin Pierce 65 | Non-league | 12.041 |
| 12/13/02 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 51 | Lindbergh 62 | League | 11.761 |
| 01/07/03 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 86 | Renton 81 | League | 2.303 |
| 12/19/03 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 64 | Kennedy 77 | League | 5.754 |
| 12/26/03 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 70 | Sedro-Woolley 58 | Non-league | 13.862 |
| 02/26/04 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 57 | Clover Park 54 | Playoff | 0.370 |
| 01/07/05 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 65 | Lindbergh 54 | League | 9.607 |
| 01/24/05 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 37 | Highline 46 | League | 0.594 |
| 12/13/05 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 70 | Tyee 54 | League | 2.016 |
| 01/23/07 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 60 | Highline 56 | League | 3.222 |
| 12/28/07 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 66 | Interlake 58 | Non-league | 2.067 |
| 01/11/08 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 50 | Hazen 49 | League | 4.120 |
| 01/15/08 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 56 | Tyee 61 | League | 1.725 |
| 01/21/09 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 53 | Hazen 61 | League | 6.307 |
| 12/08/09 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 66 | Hazen 65 | League | 4.347 |
| 01/06/10 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 59 | Highline 64 | League | 3.203 |
| 01/11/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 70 | Mount Rainier 60 | League | 3.343 |
| 01/19/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 68 | Hazen 62 | League | 4.347 |
| 01/26/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 72 | Kennedy Catholic 70 | League | 4.902 |
| 01/28/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 61 | Foster 54 | League | 4.774 |
| 02/03/10 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 38 | Highline 53 | League | 3.203 |
| 02/05/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 57 | Renton 48 | League | 0.906 |
| 02/17/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 56 | Renton 47 | Playoff | 0.906 |
| 02/26/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 63 | Prairie 50 | Playoff | 0.144 |
| 12/10/10 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 68 | Tyee 66 | League | 0.733 |
| 12/22/10 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 78 | Bonney Lake 88 | Non-league | 2.888 |
| 12/30/10 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 62 | Ingraham 67 | Non-league | 0.546 |
| 01/28/11 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 73 | Lindbergh 57 | League | 2.813 |
| 02/01/11 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 77 | Renton 74 | League | 9.354 |
| 12/01/11 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 54 | King's 53 | Non-league | 2.484 |
| 01/03/12 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 53 | Renton 45 | League | 1.834 |
| 01/06/12 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 55 | Lindbergh 47 | League | 5.187 |
| 01/27/12 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 51 | Lindbergh 48 | League | 5.187 |
| 02/04/12 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 36 | Foster 50 | League | 1.132 |
| 02/10/12 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 49 | Kingston 46 | Playoff | 8.349 |
| 02/18/12 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 52 | Port Angeles 60 | Playoff | 2.267 |
| 12/07/12 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 45 | Lindbergh 44 | League | 4.507 |
| 01/09/13 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 59 | Hazen 63 | League | 0.764 |
| 02/01/13 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 58 | Foster 52 | League | 4.779 |
| 12/12/14 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 70 | Lindbergh 69 | League | 12.524 |
| 12/17/14 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 49 | Foster 79 | League | 0.778 |
| 12/19/14 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 59 | Highline 56 | League | 1.257 |
| 01/30/15 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 52 | Renton 46 | League | 8.123 |
| 01/06/16 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 55 | Renton 49 | League | 18.800 |
| 01/22/16 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 69 | Foster 62 | League | 1.259 |
| 01/27/16 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 52 | Highline 40 | League | 7.882 |
| 11/30/16 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 58 | Tyee 59 | Non-league | 7.707 |
| 12/07/16 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 49 | Highline 44 | Non-league | 1.298 |
| 01/05/17 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 34 | Cedar Park Christian (Bothell) 45 | Non-league | 1.830 |
| 01/06/17 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 64 | White River 52 | League | 3.244 |
| 12/08/17 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 61 | Washington 60 | League | 12.180 |
| 12/04/18 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 66 | Summit Sierra 53 | Non-league | 0.771 |
| 01/22/19 | Lost | Evergreen (Highline) 57 | Tyee 62 | League | 12.425 |
| 12/19/19 | Won | Evergreen (Highline) 62 | Highline 61 | League | 2.089 |