37 Wins, 71 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/02/86 | Won | Toledo 58 | Mossyrock 56 | Non-league | 5.628 |
| 12/13/86 | Lost | Toledo 52 | Kalama 62 | Non-league | 2.943 |
| 12/04/87 | Lost | Toledo 52 | Morton 54 | Non-league | 2.063 |
| 01/28/88 | Lost | Toledo 58 | Montesano 60 | League | 11.991 |
| 02/11/88 | Won | Toledo 65 | Mossyrock 62 | Non-league | 2.435 |
| 12/02/88 | Won | Toledo 66 | Mossyrock 57 | Non-league | 1.321 |
| 03/03/89 | Won | Toledo 54 | Colfax 48 | Playoff | 3.698 |
| 03/04/89 | Lost | Toledo 42 | Prosser 55 | Playoff | 2.445 |
| 01/29/90 | Lost | Toledo 42 | Rochester 46 | League | 5.927 |
| 02/05/90 | Lost | Toledo 54 | Forks 70 | League | 2.608 |
| 02/22/90 | Lost | Toledo 30 | Castle Rock 42 | Playoff | 8.227 |
| 01/17/91 | Lost | Toledo 35 | Montesano 49 | League | 4.811 |
| 01/27/92 | Lost | Toledo 49 | Montesano 54 | League | 0.552 |
| 02/10/92 | Won | Toledo 61 | Tenino 43 | League | 2.143 |
| 12/15/93 | Won | Toledo 87 | Elma 74 | Non-league | 1.635 |
| 01/21/94 | Won | Toledo 57 | Elma 55 | League | 1.635 |
| 01/29/94 | Lost | Toledo 56 | Rochester 58 | League | 8.340 |
| 02/21/94 | Lost | Toledo 37 | Ocosta 43 | Playoff | 5.360 |
| 12/29/94 | Won | Toledo 67 | Mossyrock 48 | Non-league | 1.022 |
| 01/06/95 | Lost | Toledo 69 | Montesano 71 | League | 11.205 |
| 01/28/95 | Lost | Toledo 51 | Onalaska 55 | League | 8.105 |
| 02/02/95 | Lost | Toledo 76 | Rochester 84 | League | 10.389 |
| 02/09/95 | Lost | Toledo 53 | Forks 54 | League | 16.758 |
| 02/18/95 | Won | Toledo 61 | Castle Rock 58 | Playoff | 0.854 |
| 03/02/95 | Won | Toledo 49 | Omak 36 | Playoff | 0.076 |
| 03/03/95 | Lost | Toledo 36 | King's 53 | Playoff | 0.238 |
| 12/22/95 | Lost | Toledo 61 | White Pass 65 | League | 19.865 |
| 12/28/95 | Lost | Toledo 37 | Woodland 48 | Non-league | 13.999 |
| 02/28/96 | Lost | Toledo 42 | Seattle Christian 52 | Playoff | 6.562 |
| 03/01/96 | Won | Toledo 72 | Connell 65 | Playoff | 4.164 |
| 03/05/97 | Lost | Toledo 46 | Blaine 63 | Playoff | 2.303 |
| 12/02/97 | Lost | Toledo 48 | Castle Rock 49 | Non-league | 14.698 |
| 12/29/97 | Lost | Toledo 48 | Ocosta 50 | Non-league | 5.642 |
| 12/30/97 | Lost | Toledo 47 | Raymond 60 | Non-league | 8.768 |
| 12/15/98 | Lost | Toledo 52 | Onalaska 62 | Non-league | 0.656 |
| 12/30/98 | Lost | Toledo 43 | Raymond 52 | Non-league | 3.849 |
| 01/19/99 | Won | Toledo 79 | White Pass 64 | League | 1.380 |
| 02/04/99 | Lost | Toledo 60 | Toutle Lake 61 | League | 2.580 |
| 02/11/99 | Won | Toledo 84 | White Pass 76 | League | 1.380 |
| 02/18/99 | Lost | Toledo 34 | Raymond 54 | Playoff | 3.849 |
| 12/03/99 | Lost | Toledo 58 | Tenino 62 | Non-league | 6.397 |
| 12/07/99 | Lost | Toledo 52 | Castle Rock 65 | Non-league | 9.204 |
| 12/11/99 | Lost | Toledo 49 | Rochester 59 | Non-league | 10.860 |
| 01/17/00 | Lost | Toledo 57 | Rainier 64 | League | 4.269 |
| 02/07/00 | Won | Toledo 69 | Toutle Lake 58 | League | 3.660 |
| 02/25/00 | Won | Toledo 67 | Toutle Lake 57 | Playoff | 3.660 |
| 12/01/00 | Won | Toledo 60 | Tenino 44 | Non-league | 3.383 |
| 01/19/01 | Lost | Toledo 48 | Raymond 54 | League | 21.798 |
| 02/24/01 | Won | Toledo 66 | Toutle Lake 64 | Playoff | 2.821 |
| 03/03/01 | Won | Toledo 62 | Zillah 58 | Playoff | 8.275 |
| 12/03/02 | Won | Toledo 51 | Castle Rock 45 | Non-league | 1.936 |
| 02/03/03 | Lost | Toledo 48 | Toutle Lake 56 | League | 2.327 |
| 02/06/03 | Lost | Toledo 45 | Kalama 56 | League | 5.757 |
| 02/10/03 | Won | Toledo 59 | Napavine 50 | League | 2.270 |
| 02/20/03 | Lost | Toledo 46 | Adna 49 | Playoff | 2.621 |
| 02/22/03 | Lost | Toledo 50 | Ocosta 56 | Playoff | 9.243 |
| 12/09/03 | Lost | Toledo 51 | Winlock 53 | League | 0.044 |
| 01/29/04 | Lost | Toledo 51 | Winlock 61 | League | 0.044 |
| 02/09/04 | Won | Toledo 62 | Napavine 35 | League | 2.257 |
| 02/21/04 | Lost | Toledo 54 | Winlock 64 | Playoff | 0.044 |
| 12/21/04 | Lost | Toledo L | Rainier W | League | 8.175 |
| 01/08/05 | Won | Toledo 51 | Toutle Lake 46 | Non-league | 3.845 |
| 01/13/05 | Lost | Toledo 38 | Ilwaco 51 | League | 1.355 |
| 02/10/05 | Won | Toledo 52 | Winlock 42 | League | 1.496 |
| 02/26/05 | Lost | Toledo 50 | Ilwaco 53 | Playoff | 1.355 |
| 11/30/05 | Won | Toledo 48 | Toutle Lake 47 | Non-league | 11.734 |
| 02/01/07 | Lost | Toledo 51 | Forks 52 | League | 11.495 |
| 12/03/07 | Lost | Toledo 39 | Toutle Lake 44 | Non-league | 2.654 |
| 12/28/07 | Lost | Toledo 39 | Cedarcrest 56 | Non-league | 1.372 |
| 02/15/08 | Won | Toledo 45 | Forks 43 | Playoff | 0.587 |
| 02/22/08 | Lost | Toledo 60 | Rainier 61 | Playoff | 7.824 |
| 01/16/09 | Lost | Toledo 49 | Forks 61 | League | 14.452 |
| 01/22/09 | Lost | Toledo 50 | Winlock 52 | League | 18.150 |
| 02/12/09 | Lost | Toledo 40 | Onalaska 60 | League | 3.424 |
| 02/28/09 | Lost | Toledo 38 | Onalaska 55 | Playoff | 3.424 |
| 02/27/10 | Lost | Toledo 51 | Rainier 55 | Playoff | 5.005 |
| 03/04/10 | Lost | Toledo 34 | Vashon Island 41 | Playoff | 3.971 |
| 12/16/10 | Won | Toledo 48 | Castle Rock 45 | League | 11.908 |
| 01/07/11 | Won | Toledo 50 | Stevenson 45 | League | 6.947 |
| 01/17/11 | Won | Toledo 50 | Castle Rock 46 | League | 11.908 |
| 01/20/11 | Won | Toledo 46 | Columbia (White Salmon) 40 | League | 5.686 |
| 12/20/11 | Lost | Toledo 47 | Columbia (White Salmon) 62 | League | 1.056 |
| 01/30/12 | Lost | Toledo 40 | Columbia (White Salmon) 45 | League | 1.056 |
| 11/29/12 | Lost | Toledo 29 | Winlock 41 | Non-league | 0.251 |
| 12/07/12 | Won | Toledo 43 | Columbia (White Salmon) 38 | League | 2.335 |
| 01/03/14 | Lost | Toledo 32 | Stevenson 33 | League | 1.975 |
| 01/13/14 | Won | Toledo 42 | Columbia (White Salmon) 38 | League | 5.533 |
| 02/04/14 | Lost | Toledo 37 | Stevenson 41 | League | 1.975 |
| 01/07/15 | Lost | Toledo 41 | Pe Ell 48 | League | 7.436 |
| 01/31/15 | Lost | Toledo 43 | Pe Ell 46 | League | 7.436 |
| 01/23/16 | Won | Toledo 52 | Morton-White Pass 49 | League | 4.079 |
| 01/26/16 | Won | Toledo 38 | Onalaska 37 | League | 1.784 |
| 01/12/17 | Lost | Toledo 43 | Morton-White Pass 46 | League | 8.223 |
| 01/28/17 | Lost | Toledo 32 | Winlock 40 | League | 2.611 |
| 02/09/17 | Lost | Toledo 47 | Ocosta 50 | Playoff | 0.622 |
| 12/06/17 | Won | Toledo 43 | Mossyrock 33 | League | 5.082 |
| 02/14/18 | Lost | Toledo 44 | Adna 48 | Playoff | 1.943 |
| 12/08/18 | Lost | Toledo 38 | Adna 44 | Non-league | 3.414 |
| 12/21/18 | Won | Toledo 52 | Ilwaco 41 | Non-league | 7.822 |
| 01/15/19 | Lost | Toledo 54 | Rainier 58 | League | 7.984 |
| 01/17/19 | Lost | Toledo 44 | Adna 55 | League | 3.414 |
| 02/16/19 | Lost | Toledo 40 | Rainier 44 | Playoff | 7.984 |
| 01/23/20 | Lost | Toledo 43 | Adna 45 | League | 5.835 |
| 01/30/20 | Won | Toledo 53 | Wahkiakum 48 | League | 1.260 |
| 02/15/20 | Lost | Toledo 27 | Mossyrock 42 | Playoff | 6.140 |
| 02/29/20 | Lost | Toledo 42 | Ilwaco 44 | Playoff | 1.981 |
| 03/04/20 | Won | Toledo 50 | Colfax 48 | Playoff | 0.300 |
| 03/06/20 | Lost | Toledo 39 | Tri-Cities Prep 44 | Playoff | 0.266 |
28 Wins, 43 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/02/02 | Lost | Toledo 39 | Ilwaco 50 | Non-league | 2.560 |
| 01/06/03 | Lost | Toledo 61 | White Pass 76 | League | 5.045 |
| 01/21/03 | Lost | Toledo 56 | North Beach 57 | League | 4.042 |
| 01/31/03 | Lost | Toledo 32 | Winlock 39 | League | 1.673 |
| 12/08/03 | Lost | Toledo 48 | Winlock 50 | League | 9.864 |
| 12/18/03 | Lost | Toledo 74 | Napavine 75 | League | 1.723 |
| 01/30/04 | Lost | Toledo 51 | Winlock 59 | League | 9.864 |
| 02/27/04 | Lost | Toledo 50 | White Pass 63 | Playoff | 5.122 |
| 12/09/04 | Lost | Toledo 51 | Napavine 63 | League | 1.454 |
| 01/17/05 | Won | Toledo 54 | Brewster 42 | Non-league | 3.267 |
| 01/21/05 | Lost | Toledo 39 | Napavine 44 | League | 1.454 |
| 02/25/05 | Lost | Toledo 33 | Napavine 40 | Playoff | 1.454 |
| 03/05/05 | Lost | Toledo 36 | Napavine 42 | Playoff | 1.454 |
| 12/15/05 | Lost | Toledo 44 | Kalama 47 | League | 13.956 |
| 02/17/06 | Lost | Toledo 37 | Ilwaco 45 | Playoff | 8.417 |
| 11/29/06 | Lost | Toledo 41 | Napavine 47 | Non-league | 11.834 |
| 12/08/06 | Won | Toledo 58 | R.A. Long 47 | Non-league | 2.279 |
| 12/18/06 | Lost | Toledo 48 | Tenino 65 | League | 7.950 |
| 01/27/07 | Lost | Toledo 45 | Toutle Lake 54 | Non-league | 3.882 |
| 03/02/07 | Won | Toledo 32 | Nooksack Valley 31 | Playoff | 11.934 |
| 11/27/07 | Lost | Toledo 42 | Napavine 47 | Non-league | 3.796 |
| 12/17/07 | Lost | Toledo 66 | Tenino 71 | League | 5.585 |
| 01/09/08 | Lost | Toledo 64 | Napavine 67 | Non-league | 3.796 |
| 02/28/08 | Won | Toledo 63 | Lakeside (Nine Mile Falls) 62 | Playoff | 5.654 |
| 12/03/08 | Won | Toledo 56 | Mossyrock 54 | Non-league | 5.921 |
| 01/27/09 | Lost | Toledo 52 | Montesano 63 | League | 4.460 |
| 02/06/09 | Lost | Toledo 40 | Rochester 41 | League | 8.568 |
| 02/11/09 | Lost | Toledo 41 | Forks 55 | League | 4.964 |
| 12/29/09 | Won | Toledo 67 | Toutle Lake 53 | Non-league | 2.451 |
| 01/26/10 | Lost | Toledo 33 | Montesano 42 | League | 8.035 |
| 02/19/10 | Won | Toledo 56 | Stevenson 52 | Playoff | 3.741 |
| 12/21/10 | Won | Toledo 53 | Onalaska 51 | Non-league | 13.539 |
| 12/29/10 | Lost | Toledo 46 | Toutle Lake 50 | Non-league | 4.484 |
| 01/04/11 | Lost | Toledo 44 | Ridgefield 63 | League | 4.699 |
| 01/11/11 | Lost | Toledo 45 | Ilwaco 57 | League | 2.499 |
| 01/13/11 | Lost | Toledo 66 | Kalama 73 | League | 1.339 |
| 02/16/11 | Lost | Toledo 50 | Kalama 76 | Playoff | 1.339 |
| 02/14/12 | Lost | Toledo 64 | Kalama 70 | Playoff | 6.429 |
| 12/21/12 | Lost | Toledo 41 | Kalama 56 | League | 0.411 |
| 12/28/12 | Won | Toledo 50 | White River 47 | Non-league | 1.656 |
| 02/28/13 | Won | Toledo 58 | Okanogan 43 | Playoff | 1.104 |
| 03/01/13 | Won | Toledo 46 | Cedar Park Christian (Bothell) 39 | Playoff | 5.237 |
| 12/02/13 | Lost | Toledo 43 | Woodland 51 | League | 0.618 |
| 12/09/13 | Won | Toledo 45 | La Center 44 | League | 3.094 |
| 12/16/13 | Lost | Toledo 50 | King's Way Christian 56 | League | 5.549 |
| 12/27/13 | Won | Toledo 67 | Bremerton 59 | Non-league | 4.499 |
| 01/08/14 | Lost | Toledo 34 | Castle Rock 54 | League | 12.292 |
| 01/10/14 | Lost | Toledo 44 | Woodland 49 | League | 0.618 |
| 02/14/14 | Won | Toledo 58 | Kalama 47 | Playoff | 4.315 |
| 02/28/14 | Won | Toledo 50 | University Prep 40 | Playoff | 1.637 |
| 12/26/14 | Lost | Toledo 60 | Overlake 63 | Non-league | 3.614 |
| 01/13/15 | Lost | Toledo 47 | Adna 57 | League | 5.537 |
| 02/28/15 | Lost | Toledo 40 | Walla Walla Valley Academy 45 | Playoff | 8.913 |
| 12/05/15 | Won | Toledo 41 | Kalama 36 | Non-league | 7.050 |
| 12/10/15 | Won | Toledo 50 | Toutle Lake 43 | League | 0.600 |
| 01/20/16 | Won | Toledo 52 | Napavine 41 | League | 2.832 |
| 01/22/16 | Won | Toledo 66 | Toutle Lake 45 | League | 0.600 |
| 02/05/16 | Lost | Toledo 65 | Adna 75 | League | 2.039 |
| 02/13/16 | Lost | Toledo 41 | Adna 49 | Playoff | 2.039 |
| 02/01/17 | Won | Toledo 60 | Toutle Lake 55 | League | 1.924 |
| 02/15/17 | Won | Toledo 73 | Napavine 48 | Playoff | 5.117 |
| 12/14/17 | Won | Toledo 54 | Toutle Lake 45 | League | 3.830 |
| 01/12/18 | Won | Toledo 57 | Morton-White Pass 49 | League | 5.450 |
| 01/31/18 | Won | Toledo 58 | Toutle Lake 56 | League | 3.830 |
| 12/11/18 | Lost | Toledo 46 | Toutle Lake 50 | Non-league | 7.120 |
| 02/23/19 | Lost | Toledo 47 | Life Christian 56 | Playoff | 2.960 |
| 12/18/19 | Won | Toledo 46 | Adna 41 | Non-league | 14.636 |
| 12/20/19 | Lost | Toledo 45 | Hoquiam 59 | Non-league | 0.534 |
| 01/04/20 | Won | Toledo 51 | Darrington 45 | Non-league | 1.446 |
| 01/15/20 | Won | Toledo 48 | Morton-White Pass 46 | League | 11.207 |
| 01/31/20 | Won | Toledo 52 | Kalama 50 | League | 4.150 |