8 Wins, 10 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/05/11 | Won | Seton Catholic 79 | Columbia (White Salmon) 20 | Non-league | 8.384 |
| 01/31/12 | Lost | Seton Catholic 53 | Three Rivers Christian 58 | League | 13.104 |
| 12/21/12 | Won | Seton Catholic 45 | King's Way Christian 27 | League | 4.799 |
| 12/20/13 | Lost | Seton Catholic 24 | King's Way Christian 26 | League | 10.655 |
| 01/10/14 | Won | Seton Catholic 30 | Castle Rock 21 | League | 2.775 |
| 12/06/14 | Won | Seton Catholic 59 | Tenino 35 | Non-league | 0.588 |
| 12/16/14 | Lost | Seton Catholic 24 | Castle Rock 36 | League | 4.139 |
| 12/22/14 | Lost | Seton Catholic 31 | Fort Vancouver 39 | Non-league | 1.309 |
| 01/06/15 | Lost | Seton Catholic 38 | Castle Rock 42 | Non-league | 4.139 |
| 01/17/15 | Lost | Seton Catholic 30 | Castle Rock 36 | League | 4.139 |
| 01/21/16 | Lost | Seton Catholic 23 | Castle Rock 31 | League | 1.743 |
| 01/30/16 | Won | Seton Catholic 43 | Stevenson 37 | League | 5.233 |
| 12/22/16 | Won | Seton Catholic 48 | Tenino 42 | Non-league | 4.106 |
| 01/26/17 | Lost | Seton Catholic 41 | Stevenson 52 | League | 10.783 |
| 12/06/17 | Won | Seton Catholic 50 | Columbia Adventist 47 | Non-league | 12.437 |
| 12/07/18 | Lost | Seton Catholic 45 | Kalama 47 | Non-league | 0.397 |
| 12/15/18 | Lost | Seton Catholic 48 | Columbia Adventist 56 | Non-league | 3.337 |
| 01/14/20 | Won | Seton Catholic 46 | King's Way Christian 40 | League | 12.617 |
18 Wins, 18 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/15/09 | Lost | Seton Catholic 27 | Washington School for the Deaf 48 | League | 1.038 |
| 01/21/10 | Lost | Seton Catholic 43 | Washington School for the Deaf 49 | League | 1.038 |
| 01/25/11 | Lost | Seton Catholic 51 | Vancouver Christian 63 | League | 4.890 |
| 02/16/11 | Lost | Seton Catholic 57 | Mary M. Knight 72 | Playoff | 3.292 |
| 12/02/11 | Lost | Seton Catholic 39 | Wishkah Valley 42 | Non-league | 4.116 |
| 12/28/11 | Won | Seton Catholic 47 | Liberty Christian 42 | Non-league | 10.618 |
| 01/17/12 | Won | Seton Catholic 56 | King's Way Christian 55 | League | 9.002 |
| 12/08/12 | Lost | Seton Catholic 30 | Mary M. Knight 42 | Non-league | 2.020 |
| 12/21/12 | Won | Seton Catholic 46 | King's Way Christian 34 | League | 8.425 |
| 01/10/13 | Won | Seton Catholic 56 | Columbia (White Salmon) 39 | League | 5.734 |
| 01/17/13 | Lost | Seton Catholic 42 | Stevenson 53 | League | 4.409 |
| 01/24/14 | Won | Seton Catholic 72 | Stevenson 67 | League | 0.418 |
| 01/29/14 | Won | Seton Catholic 52 | La Center 51 | League | 26.205 |
| 12/06/14 | Won | Seton Catholic 59 | Tenino 55 | Non-league | 0.048 |
| 12/23/14 | Won | Seton Catholic 69 | Columbia (White Salmon) 46 | League | 0.778 |
| 01/30/15 | Won | Seton Catholic 92 | Stevenson 77 | League | 0.212 |
| 12/30/15 | Won | Seton Catholic 63 | Ilwaco 38 | Non-league | 2.509 |
| 01/11/16 | Lost | Seton Catholic 53 | Columbia (White Salmon) 65 | League | 6.416 |
| 01/27/16 | Lost | Seton Catholic 73 | Stevenson 81 | League | 0.278 |
| 01/30/16 | Lost | Seton Catholic 60 | Stevenson 62 | League | 0.278 |
| 12/31/16 | Won | Seton Catholic 63 | Heritage 61 | Non-league | 15.286 |
| 01/23/17 | Lost | Seton Catholic 64 | Columbia (White Salmon) 74 | League | 8.948 |
| 01/05/18 | Lost | Seton Catholic 64 | Columbia (White Salmon) 66 | League | 14.230 |
| 01/13/18 | Won | Seton Catholic 58 | King's 55 | Non-league | 14.000 |
| 01/18/18 | Won | Seton Catholic 65 | King's Way Christian 64 | League | 9.460 |
| 01/20/18 | Won | Seton Catholic 74 | Montesano 71 | Non-league | 16.700 |
| 01/25/18 | Lost | Seton Catholic 77 | Stevenson 80 | League | 4.510 |
| 02/09/18 | Won | Seton Catholic 65 | Forks 62 | Playoff | 1.270 |
| 12/05/18 | Lost | Seton Catholic 52 | Hudson's Bay 68 | Non-league | 8.249 |
| 01/08/19 | Won | Seton Catholic 73 | King's Way Christian 65 | League | 4.600 |
| 02/07/19 | Lost | Seton Catholic 68 | Montesano 70 | Playoff | 9.974 |
| 02/23/19 | Lost | Seton Catholic 48 | Bellevue Christian 58 | Playoff | 3.762 |
| 12/05/19 | Lost | Seton Catholic 53 | Hudson's Bay 54 | Non-league | 17.826 |
| 12/13/19 | Lost | Seton Catholic 57 | R.A. Long 66 | Non-league | 2.505 |
| 12/28/19 | Won | Seton Catholic 76 | W.F. West 74 | Non-league | 1.225 |
| 02/18/20 | Won | Seton Catholic 69 | King's Way Christian 48 | Playoff | 13.795 |