19 Wins, 34 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/30/87 | Won | Neah Bay 64 | Quilcene 63 | League | 9.728 |
| 12/12/87 | Won | Neah Bay 53 | Watson Groen Christian 35 | Non-league | 8.190 |
| 12/30/87 | Lost | Neah Bay 31 | La Conner 43 | Non-league | 11.790 |
| 01/06/89 | Lost | Neah Bay 45 | Quilcene 54 | League | 1.255 |
| 01/20/89 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | Quilcene 52 | League | 1.255 |
| 02/25/89 | Lost | Neah Bay 59 | Watson Groen Christian 60 | Playoff | 5.446 |
| 12/30/89 | Lost | Neah Bay 51 | Lake Quinault 52 | Non-league | 7.991 |
| 01/17/90 | Lost | Neah Bay 47 | Forks 65 | Non-league | 0.473 |
| 03/01/90 | Lost | Neah Bay 58 | Orcas Island 68 | Playoff | 0.857 |
| 12/22/90 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | La Conner 67 | Non-league | 2.872 |
| 02/15/91 | Lost | Neah Bay 53 | Seattle Lutheran 58 | Playoff | 3.511 |
| 02/18/91 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | Tacoma Baptist 59 | Playoff | 13.047 |
| 12/20/91 | Lost | Neah Bay 54 | Adna 57 | Non-league | 0.665 |
| 01/11/92 | Lost | Neah Bay 40 | North Beach 45 | Non-league | 8.312 |
| 02/22/92 | Lost | Neah Bay 41 | Watson Groen Christian 61 | Playoff | 0.316 |
| 01/15/93 | Lost | Neah Bay 41 | Quilcene 49 | League | 1.779 |
| 02/09/93 | Won | Neah Bay 56 | Clallam Bay 53 | League | 15.262 |
| 02/16/93 | Lost | Neah Bay 41 | King's West 52 | Playoff | 3.749 |
| 12/16/95 | Won | Neah Bay 55 | Clallam Bay 48 | League | 15.055 |
| 01/19/96 | Won | Neah Bay 45 | Crescent 42 | League | 2.197 |
| 12/13/96 | Lost | Neah Bay L | Inchelium W | Non-league | 1.575 |
| 02/21/98 | Won | Neah Bay W | Clallam Bay L | Playoff | 17.437 |
| 01/26/99 | Lost | Neah Bay 52 | Clallam Bay 57 | League | 2.228 |
| 01/04/00 | Won | Neah Bay 56 | Clallam Bay 48 | League | 0.745 |
| 01/19/02 | Lost | Neah Bay 43 | Chief Leschi 44 | Non-league | 5.693 |
| 12/29/03 | Lost | Neah Bay 39 | La Conner 40 | Non-league | 3.596 |
| 12/10/04 | Won | Neah Bay 48 | Seattle Lutheran 40 | Non-league | 2.147 |
| 12/30/05 | Lost | Neah Bay 40 | Darrington 50 | Non-league | 1.638 |
| 02/17/06 | Lost | Neah Bay 62 | Lummi Nation 70 | Playoff | 3.168 |
| 12/12/07 | Lost | Neah Bay 43 | Clallam Bay 61 | League | 10.013 |
| 12/27/07 | Won | Neah Bay 53 | La Conner 49 | Non-league | 14.843 |
| 01/11/08 | Lost | Neah Bay 49 | Clallam Bay 52 | League | 10.013 |
| 02/09/08 | Won | Neah Bay 51 | North Sound Christian 47 | Playoff | 1.576 |
| 02/21/08 | Won | Neah Bay 62 | Lake Quinault 52 | Playoff | 1.900 |
| 02/22/08 | Won | Neah Bay 61 | Trout Lake-Glenwood 59 | Playoff | 3.360 |
| 02/17/09 | Won | Neah Bay 51 | Lummi Nation 47 | Playoff | 4.489 |
| 02/18/11 | Lost | Neah Bay 33 | Lopez 45 | Playoff | 27.488 |
| 03/05/11 | Won | Neah Bay 52 | Selkirk 50 | Playoff | 0.524 |
| 02/14/13 | Lost | Neah Bay 36 | Tulalip Heritage 44 | Playoff | 2.113 |
| 02/18/13 | Lost | Neah Bay 38 | Mount Vernon Christian 46 | Playoff | 0.710 |
| 02/19/15 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | Crosspoint 59 | Playoff | 5.502 |
| 12/09/15 | Won | Neah Bay 55 | Sequim 35 | Non-league | 0.173 |
| 12/21/15 | Lost | Neah Bay 46 | Tulalip Heritage 51 | Non-league | 0.580 |
| 02/27/16 | Lost | Neah Bay 40 | Taholah 48 | Playoff | 5.751 |
| 12/09/16 | Won | Neah Bay 41 | Mount Vernon Christian 30 | Non-league | 1.483 |
| 12/30/16 | Lost | Neah Bay 41 | Bellingham 55 | Non-league | 0.532 |
| 01/04/17 | Won | Neah Bay 45 | Sequim 42 | Non-league | 8.630 |
| 01/14/17 | Lost | Neah Bay 51 | Evergreen Lutheran 53 | Non-league | 5.903 |
| 01/31/18 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | Clallam Bay 63 | League | 17.290 |
| 02/24/18 | Won | Neah Bay 52 | Selkirk 43 | Playoff | 4.968 |
| 03/02/19 | Won | Neah Bay 67 | Almira Coulee Hartline 56 | Playoff | 3.724 |
| 01/09/20 | Lost | Neah Bay 51 | Forks 59 | Non-league | 17.087 |
| 03/06/20 | Lost | Neah Bay 53 | Curlew 55 | Playoff | 7.256 |
27 Wins, 30 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/16/02 | Won | Neah Bay 60 | Chief Leschi 59 | Non-league | 12.283 |
| 12/28/02 | Lost | Neah Bay 48 | Wishkah Valley 54 | Non-league | 9.922 |
| 12/19/03 | Lost | Neah Bay 65 | Shoreline Christian 73 | Non-league | 4.827 |
| 02/24/04 | Lost | Neah Bay 43 | Darrington 45 | Playoff | 5.487 |
| 03/05/04 | Lost | Neah Bay 66 | Darrington 68 | Playoff | 5.487 |
| 12/01/04 | Lost | Neah Bay 73 | Northwest Christian (Lacey) 76 | Non-league | 5.964 |
| 02/02/05 | Won | Neah Bay 49 | Clallam Bay 38 | League | 1.305 |
| 03/02/05 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | Selkirk 53 | Playoff | 7.582 |
| 03/03/05 | Won | Neah Bay 63 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 56 | Playoff | 4.408 |
| 03/04/05 | Won | Neah Bay 58 | Clallam Bay 57 | Playoff | 1.305 |
| 02/17/06 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | Mount Vernon Christian 65 | Playoff | 7.583 |
| 03/04/06 | Won | Neah Bay 58 | Sunnyside Christian 50 | Playoff | 3.786 |
| 12/08/06 | Won | Neah Bay 54 | Lummi Nation 41 | Non-league | 0.086 |
| 12/09/06 | Lost | Neah Bay 56 | Chief Leschi 70 | Non-league | 4.130 |
| 12/20/06 | Won | Neah Bay 74 | Rainier Christian 50 | Non-league | 2.498 |
| 12/27/06 | Won | Neah Bay 56 | Quilcene 35 | Non-league | 1.034 |
| 01/06/07 | Won | Neah Bay 52 | King's West 48 | Non-league | 7.093 |
| 01/19/07 | Lost | Neah Bay 43 | Crescent 58 | League | 2.265 |
| 01/26/07 | Lost | Neah Bay 52 | Clallam Bay 53 | League | 6.791 |
| 02/22/07 | Lost | Neah Bay 52 | Taholah 62 | Playoff | 4.729 |
| 12/08/07 | Lost | Neah Bay 55 | Chief Leschi 64 | Non-league | 16.663 |
| 12/22/07 | Won | Neah Bay 55 | Northwest Christian (Lacey) 53 | Non-league | 2.326 |
| 12/16/08 | Won | Neah Bay 55 | Clallam Bay 51 | Non-league | 5.484 |
| 01/09/09 | Won | Neah Bay 58 | Clallam Bay 54 | League | 5.484 |
| 01/13/09 | Won | Neah Bay 74 | Kingston 71 | Non-league | 4.996 |
| 12/11/09 | Lost | Neah Bay 46 | King's West 50 | Non-league | 7.370 |
| 12/29/09 | Won | Neah Bay 78 | Lummi Nation 76 | Non-league | 2.136 |
| 02/25/10 | Lost | Neah Bay 48 | Pateros 51 | Playoff | 1.639 |
| 12/21/10 | Lost | Neah Bay 49 | Tulalip Heritage 55 | Non-league | 19.150 |
| 02/05/11 | Won | Neah Bay 75 | Klahowya 52 | Non-league | 1.440 |
| 02/15/11 | Lost | Neah Bay 59 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 67 | Playoff | 2.921 |
| 02/25/11 | Lost | Neah Bay 40 | Mount Rainier Lutheran 62 | Playoff | 2.921 |
| 03/03/11 | Won | Neah Bay 49 | Rosalia 41 | Playoff | 17.941 |
| 03/04/11 | Won | Neah Bay 63 | Colton 60 | Playoff | 3.542 |
| 02/18/13 | Lost | Neah Bay 64 | Cedar Park Christian (Mountlake Terrace) 65 | Playoff | 9.326 |
| 03/01/13 | Won | Neah Bay 77 | LaCrosse-Washtucna-Kahlotus 60 | Playoff | 0.055 |
| 01/11/14 | Won | Neah Bay 56 | Lummi Nation 53 | Non-league | 2.777 |
| 02/18/14 | Won | Neah Bay 72 | Lummi Nation 64 | Playoff | 2.777 |
| 02/22/14 | Lost | Neah Bay 66 | Tulalip Heritage 68 | Playoff | 1.246 |
| 12/09/15 | Lost | Neah Bay 60 | Sequim 65 | Non-league | 3.890 |
| 12/15/15 | Lost | Neah Bay 40 | Shorewood Christian 56 | Non-league | 2.684 |
| 12/29/15 | Won | Neah Bay 56 | Nooksack Valley 49 | Non-league | 3.896 |
| 03/04/16 | Won | Neah Bay 61 | Sunnyside Christian 58 | Playoff | 0.665 |
| 03/05/16 | Won | Neah Bay 73 | Almira Coulee Hartline 48 | Playoff | 5.532 |
| 12/16/16 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | Forks 77 | Non-league | 2.261 |
| 12/19/16 | Lost | Neah Bay 76 | Taholah 83 | Non-league | 6.743 |
| 02/25/17 | Lost | Neah Bay 72 | Almira Coulee Hartline 79 | Playoff | 3.050 |
| 12/16/17 | Won | Neah Bay 61 | Darrington 55 | Non-league | 2.370 |
| 12/07/18 | Lost | Neah Bay 65 | Darrington 70 | Non-league | 6.895 |
| 12/28/18 | Lost | Neah Bay 41 | Charles Wright 45 | Non-league | 7.092 |
| 01/12/19 | Lost | Neah Bay 49 | La Conner 63 | Non-league | 5.148 |
| 02/15/19 | Won | Neah Bay 66 | Tulalip Heritage 44 | Playoff | 3.919 |
| 01/10/20 | Lost | Neah Bay 40 | Crescent 43 | League | 8.188 |
| 02/05/20 | Lost | Neah Bay 50 | Crescent 52 | League | 8.188 |
| 02/10/20 | Won | Neah Bay 50 | Chief Kitsap 42 | League | 2.175 |
| 02/13/20 | Won | Neah Bay 56 | Chief Kitsap 47 | League | 2.175 |
| 02/15/20 | Lost | Neah Bay 53 | Lopez 54 | Playoff | 10.592 |