38 Wins, 17 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/30/87 | Lost | Colton 32 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 36 | League | 5.238 |
| 01/15/88 | Won | Colton 36 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 29 | League | 8.919 |
| 01/03/89 | Won | Colton 40 | Waitsburg 34 | Non-league | 7.701 |
| 01/13/89 | Won | Colton 46 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 44 | League | 8.684 |
| 01/14/89 | Lost | Colton 26 | Rosalia 36 | League | 2.829 |
| 01/28/89 | Lost | Colton 44 | Rosalia 48 | League | 2.829 |
| 02/10/89 | Lost | Colton 28 | Rosalia 37 | Playoff | 2.829 |
| 01/16/93 | Won | Colton 55 | Rosalia 54 | League | 5.494 |
| 01/26/93 | Won | Colton 70 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 68 | League | 0.650 |
| 01/30/93 | Won | Colton 76 | St. John-Endicott 66 | League | 19.977 |
| 02/12/93 | Won | Colton 67 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 63 | Playoff | 0.650 |
| 01/29/94 | Won | Colton 48 | Garfield-Palouse 47 | League | 12.729 |
| 02/12/94 | Lost | Colton 41 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 58 | Playoff | 8.933 |
| 12/13/94 | Won | Colton 61 | Pomeroy 52 | Non-league | 1.913 |
| 02/03/95 | Won | Colton 58 | Garfield-Palouse 51 | League | 1.745 |
| 02/07/95 | Won | Colton 42 | Tekoa-Oakesdale 36 | Playoff | 3.677 |
| 12/19/95 | Won | Colton 59 | Asotin 50 | Non-league | 1.582 |
| 02/12/96 | Won | Colton 48 | Tekoa-Oakesdale 39 | Playoff | 0.063 |
| 02/17/96 | Won | Colton 36 | Pomeroy 32 | Playoff | 0.698 |
| 01/07/97 | Won | Colton 39 | Walla Walla Valley Academy 35 | Non-league | 0.816 |
| 02/04/97 | Won | Colton 56 | Walla Walla Valley Academy 46 | Non-league | 0.816 |
| 02/06/98 | Won | Colton 46 | Rosalia 45 | League | 13.237 |
| 12/11/98 | Won | Colton 48 | Pomeroy 39 | Non-league | 10.794 |
| 01/22/99 | Won | Colton 54 | Rosalia 45 | League | 9.727 |
| 12/16/00 | Won | Colton 54 | Rosalia 36 | League | 7.554 |
| 01/19/01 | Lost | Colton 33 | St. John-Endicott 37 | League | 0.910 |
| 02/09/01 | Won | Colton 45 | Rosalia 43 | Playoff | 7.554 |
| 12/14/01 | Won | Colton 48 | Garfield-Palouse 40 | League | 0.220 |
| 12/18/01 | Won | Colton 39 | Waitsburg 37 | Non-league | 2.746 |
| 01/18/02 | Won | Colton 49 | Rosalia 39 | League | 11.619 |
| 01/31/03 | Won | Colton 49 | Garfield-Palouse 47 | League | 17.662 |
| 02/14/03 | Won | Colton 48 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 42 | Playoff | 10.553 |
| 01/24/04 | Lost | Colton 35 | Rosalia 39 | League | 6.953 |
| 02/07/04 | Won | Colton 65 | St. John-Endicott 44 | League | 4.236 |
| 12/02/04 | Lost | Colton 41 | Waitsburg 49 | Non-league | 10.192 |
| 01/22/05 | Lost | Colton 43 | Asotin 53 | League | 2.166 |
| 02/12/05 | Won | Colton 66 | St. John-Endicott 51 | Playoff | 12.260 |
| 12/20/05 | Won | Colton 42 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 41 | Non-league | 6.102 |
| 01/14/06 | Won | Colton 59 | St. John-Endicott 55 | League | 10.372 |
| 02/18/06 | Lost | Colton 45 | DeSales 54 | Playoff | 1.030 |
| 01/02/07 | Won | Colton 67 | Sprague-Harrington 66 | League | 10.814 |
| 02/02/07 | Won | Colton 44 | Tekoa-Oakesdale 37 | League | 2.195 |
| 02/09/07 | Won | Colton 53 | Tekoa-Oakesdale 36 | Playoff | 2.195 |
| 02/24/07 | Won | Colton 45 | Tekoa-Oakesdale 42 | Playoff | 2.195 |
| 12/15/07 | Won | Colton 32 | Garfield-Palouse 27 | League | 0.014 |
| 02/04/08 | Lost | Colton 51 | Tekoa-Oakesdale 53 | League | 7.488 |
| 02/02/10 | Lost | Colton 52 | St. John-Endicott 56 | League | 19.532 |
| 02/25/11 | Lost | Colton 43 | Almira Coulee Hartline 45 | Playoff | 11.869 |
| 01/13/17 | Lost | Colton 50 | Oakesdale 55 | League | 13.626 |
| 03/03/17 | Lost | Colton 46 | Almira Coulee Hartline 50 | Playoff | 15.428 |
| 12/27/18 | Lost | Colton 54 | Davenport 57 | Non-league | 9.729 |
| 12/27/19 | Won | Colton 51 | Waterville-Mansfield 41 | Non-league | 0.679 |
| 12/28/19 | Won | Colton 58 | Wahkiakum 48 | Non-league | 4.100 |
| 02/01/20 | Won | Colton 52 | Oakesdale 45 | League | 2.707 |
| 02/21/20 | Lost | Colton 40 | Garfield-Palouse 44 | Playoff | 6.867 |
22 Wins, 27 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/24/03 | Won | Colton 53 | Asotin 40 | League | 4.022 |
| 01/23/04 | Won | Colton 57 | Asotin 49 | League | 8.496 |
| 12/05/06 | Lost | Colton 46 | Waitsburg 61 | Non-league | 6.247 |
| 12/22/06 | Won | Colton 62 | Sprague-Harrington 41 | Non-league | 2.416 |
| 01/02/07 | Won | Colton 59 | Sprague-Harrington 50 | League | 2.416 |
| 01/05/07 | Won | Colton 51 | Rosalia 43 | League | 8.573 |
| 02/03/07 | Won | Colton 67 | LaCrosse-Washtucna 66 | League | 4.905 |
| 12/28/07 | Lost | Colton 47 | Columbia (Hunters) 53 | Non-league | 2.427 |
| 12/29/07 | Won | Colton 66 | Soap Lake 58 | Non-league | 2.473 |
| 01/07/09 | Lost | Colton 40 | Pomeroy 51 | League | 1.276 |
| 01/10/09 | Won | Colton 52 | Touchet 37 | Non-league | 2.436 |
| 01/31/09 | Won | Colton 47 | Touchet 44 | Non-league | 2.436 |
| 01/05/10 | Lost | Colton 57 | Tri-Cities Prep 62 | Non-league | 0.107 |
| 01/09/10 | Lost | Colton 52 | Touchet 65 | Non-league | 1.892 |
| 01/26/10 | Lost | Colton 49 | St. John-Endicott 61 | League | 0.216 |
| 02/02/10 | Lost | Colton 64 | St. John-Endicott 68 | League | 0.216 |
| 02/11/10 | Lost | Colton 54 | Touchet 70 | Playoff | 1.892 |
| 02/19/10 | Lost | Colton 50 | Touchet 54 | Playoff | 1.892 |
| 01/11/11 | Won | Colton 77 | Asotin 69 | Non-league | 1.418 |
| 01/22/11 | Lost | Colton 44 | Touchet 57 | League | 11.569 |
| 02/25/11 | Won | Colton 66 | Wellpinit 55 | Playoff | 5.490 |
| 03/04/11 | Lost | Colton 60 | Neah Bay 63 | Playoff | 3.542 |
| 02/24/12 | Lost | Colton 55 | Almira Coulee Hartline 61 | Playoff | 8.160 |
| 01/11/13 | Lost | Colton 53 | Rosalia 62 | League | 5.179 |
| 01/29/13 | Lost | Colton 56 | Pomeroy 62 | League | 3.861 |
| 02/01/13 | Won | Colton 66 | Garfield-Palouse 47 | League | 1.720 |
| 02/02/13 | Won | Colton 59 | LaCrosse-Washtucna-Kahlotus 43 | League | 1.248 |
| 02/09/13 | Lost | Colton 52 | Pomeroy 72 | Playoff | 3.861 |
| 02/12/13 | Lost | Colton 49 | Rosalia 61 | Playoff | 5.179 |
| 01/04/14 | Lost | Colton 83 | Rosalia 90 | League | 8.253 |
| 01/14/14 | Won | Colton 45 | Garfield-Palouse 37 | League | 8.893 |
| 01/17/14 | Lost | Colton 45 | Rosalia 73 | League | 8.253 |
| 02/22/14 | Won | Colton 66 | Garfield-Palouse 60 | Playoff | 8.893 |
| 03/08/14 | Won | Colton 59 | Pomeroy 46 | Playoff | 2.546 |
| 02/17/15 | Lost | Colton 53 | Touchet 54 | Playoff | 10.766 |
| 01/08/16 | Won | Colton 70 | Touchet 56 | League | 1.484 |
| 01/23/16 | Won | Colton 53 | Touchet 52 | League | 1.484 |
| 01/29/16 | Won | Colton 58 | Liberty Christian 56 | League | 13.059 |
| 01/30/16 | Won | Colton 55 | Pomeroy 53 | League | 9.349 |
| 12/16/16 | Lost | Colton 55 | Garfield-Palouse 62 | League | 5.143 |
| 01/14/17 | Lost | Colton 68 | Prescott 74 | League | 9.306 |
| 01/28/17 | Lost | Colton 49 | Waitsburg 62 | League | 1.908 |
| 02/11/17 | Lost | Colton 50 | Waitsburg 62 | Playoff | 1.908 |
| 02/24/17 | Lost | Colton 55 | Wellpinit 62 | Playoff | 1.567 |
| 12/09/17 | Lost | Colton 49 | Touchet 52 | League | 1.440 |
| 01/20/18 | Lost | Colton 34 | Touchet 45 | League | 1.440 |
| 12/15/18 | Won | Colton 55 | Pomeroy 44 | League | 3.769 |
| 12/27/18 | Won | Colton 63 | Davenport 53 | Non-league | 2.406 |
| 02/10/20 | Lost | Colton 39 | Touchet 46 | League | 0.362 |