17 Wins, 20 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/30/87 | Lost | Bickleton 36 | Klickitat 41 | Non-league | 7.222 |
| 02/07/87 | Won | Bickleton 42 | Trout Lake 33 | Non-league | 7.809 |
| 12/17/88 | Lost | Bickleton 38 | Trout Lake 50 | League | 4.975 |
| 12/20/90 | Lost | Bickleton 36 | Klickitat 50 | League | 10.008 |
| 12/04/92 | Lost | Bickleton 32 | Prescott 39 | Non-league | 0.075 |
| 12/05/92 | Lost | Bickleton 30 | Wahluke 33 | Non-league | 9.496 |
| 02/07/95 | Lost | Bickleton 55 | Yakama Tribal 69 | League | 4.222 |
| 12/17/96 | Won | Bickleton 31 | Mabton 23 | Non-league | 4.755 |
| 01/18/05 | Lost | Bickleton 28 | Tri-Cities Prep 33 | Non-league | 5.729 |
| 01/12/06 | Won | Bickleton 34 | Lyle 31 | League | 10.439 |
| 01/16/07 | Won | Bickleton 38 | Lyle 37 | League | 8.500 |
| 01/20/07 | Lost | Bickleton 44 | Yakama Tribal 45 | League | 1.406 |
| 01/25/08 | Lost | Bickleton 59 | Klickitat 62 | League | 1.956 |
| 01/16/09 | Won | Bickleton 46 | Klickitat 42 | League | 5.658 |
| 01/17/09 | Lost | Bickleton 38 | Lyle/Wishram 39 | Non-league | 4.564 |
| 02/14/09 | Won | Bickleton 49 | Trout Lake-Glenwood 31 | Playoff | 3.547 |
| 02/17/09 | Won | Bickleton 42 | Klickitat 39 | Playoff | 5.658 |
| 01/15/10 | Lost | Bickleton 37 | Klickitat 43 | League | 6.104 |
| 01/23/10 | Won | Bickleton 66 | Trout Lake-Glenwood 55 | League | 1.876 |
| 02/16/10 | Won | Bickleton 54 | Trout Lake-Glenwood 39 | Playoff | 1.876 |
| 01/07/11 | Lost | Bickleton 50 | Trout Lake-Glenwood 58 | League | 4.826 |
| 01/22/11 | Lost | Bickleton 49 | Trout Lake-Glenwood 54 | League | 4.826 |
| 12/09/11 | Won | Bickleton 50 | Columbia (White Salmon) 35 | Non-league | 3.903 |
| 01/28/12 | Lost | Bickleton 28 | Klickitat 36 | League | 5.900 |
| 01/04/13 | Lost | Bickleton 40 | Klickitat 48 | Non-league | 2.611 |
| 01/18/13 | Won | Bickleton 44 | Lyle/Wishram 33 | League | 5.154 |
| 01/26/13 | Lost | Bickleton 36 | Trout Lake-Glenwood 48 | League | 0.142 |
| 01/09/15 | Lost | Bickleton 48 | Yakama Tribal 54 | League | 7.359 |
| 01/16/15 | Won | Bickleton 68 | Lyle/Wishram 56 | League | 0.462 |
| 01/24/15 | Lost | Bickleton 51 | Yakama Tribal 60 | League | 7.359 |
| 01/30/15 | Won | Bickleton 50 | Lyle/Wishram 44 | League | 0.462 |
| 02/17/15 | Won | Bickleton 34 | Lyle/Wishram 33 | Playoff | 0.462 |
| 12/28/15 | Won | Bickleton 61 | Walla Walla Valley Academy 40 | Non-league | 3.953 |
| 01/13/17 | Won | Bickleton 49 | Klickitat/Glenwood 46 | League | 5.936 |
| 01/20/17 | Lost | Bickleton 26 | Trout Lake 36 | League | 4.491 |
| 01/23/17 | Lost | Bickleton 33 | Lyle/Wishram 39 | Non-league | 3.998 |
| 02/10/17 | Won | Bickleton 42 | Klickitat/Glenwood 32 | Playoff | 5.936 |
13 Wins, 14 Losses
| Date | Game Type | Upset Magnitude | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/06/02 | Lost | Bickleton 41 | Tri-Cities Prep 42 | Non-league | 0.354 |
| 12/10/02 | Won | Bickleton 46 | Jubilee Christian 44 | Non-league | 6.453 |
| 12/07/04 | Lost | Bickleton 43 | Jubilee Christian 45 | Non-league | 2.584 |
| 01/18/05 | Lost | Bickleton 43 | Jubilee Christian 48 | Non-league | 2.584 |
| 01/12/06 | Won | Bickleton 58 | Lyle 36 | League | 11.398 |
| 12/04/07 | Won | Bickleton 64 | Columbia Basin 54 | Non-league | 0.840 |
| 12/11/07 | Won | Bickleton 46 | Columbia Basin 39 | Non-league | 0.840 |
| 02/12/08 | Lost | Bickleton 46 | Yakama Tribal 51 | League | 7.820 |
| 01/18/11 | Won | Bickleton 44 | Yakama Tribal 43 | League | 15.615 |
| 01/31/12 | Won | Bickleton 42 | Trout Lake-Glenwood 36 | League | 11.605 |
| 02/03/12 | Won | Bickleton 61 | Yakama Tribal 57 | League | 6.465 |
| 01/03/14 | Lost | Bickleton 31 | Klickitat 41 | Non-league | 5.743 |
| 12/05/14 | Lost | Bickleton 48 | Moses Lake Christian 54 | Non-league | 8.992 |
| 12/16/14 | Won | Bickleton 54 | Touchet 45 | Non-league | 5.913 |
| 12/18/14 | Lost | Bickleton 38 | Moses Lake Christian 45 | Non-league | 8.992 |
| 12/30/14 | Lost | Bickleton 40 | Klickitat 47 | Non-league | 12.703 |
| 01/10/15 | Lost | Bickleton 50 | Trout Lake 55 | League | 10.281 |
| 02/14/15 | Won | Bickleton 59 | Lyle/Wishram 55 | Playoff | 6.166 |
| 02/02/16 | Won | Bickleton 61 | Yakama Tribal 53 | League | 14.027 |
| 12/02/16 | Lost | Bickleton 46 | Riverside Christian 47 | Non-league | 15.763 |
| 01/28/17 | Lost | Bickleton 52 | Lyle/Wishram 56 | Non-league | 2.085 |
| 02/10/17 | Lost | Bickleton 41 | Klickitat/Glenwood 48 | Playoff | 1.360 |
| 12/01/17 | Won | Bickleton 61 | Riverside Christian 56 | Non-league | 5.300 |
| 01/12/18 | Won | Bickleton 51 | Klickitat/Glenwood 42 | League | 4.170 |
| 12/04/18 | Lost | Bickleton 45 | Touchet 53 | Non-league | 6.509 |
| 02/02/19 | Lost | Bickleton 34 | Klickitat/Glenwood 43 | League | 15.348 |
| 12/10/19 | Won | Bickleton 40 | Touchet 32 | Non-league | 4.811 |